An EMG Comparison Study of a Leg Press and a Squat Lift Melissa James MPT, Heidi Ivesdal, Thomas Mohr PT, PhD, John Frappier MS Dept. Although the leg press is a good workout addition, especially if you want to build strong quads, the potential for injury may be greater than with squats. The purpose of this study was to compare muscle recruitment during a leg press and a traditional squat lift. In fact, around 60% of my readers feel that the hip thrust (40%) or barbell glute bridge (19%) is the best glute exercise (see HERE for the results to a poll), with the remaining 40% coming from the squat (8%), deadlift (7%), Bulgarian split squat (6%), kettlebell swing (5%), single leg RDL (4%), lunge (4%), single leg hip thrust (3%), and back extension (3%). Relative EMG activity of all four heads of the quadriceps during hack squat, leg press, squat and leg extension variations in comparison to barbell squatting to parallel (knee angle 75); data adapted from Boeckh-Behrens & Buskies. 5 The exercises performed were the leg press and the barbell squat lift. It was expected that muscle activity of the leg muscles would be greater in the unilateral lifts than in the bilateral back squats. Second aim was developing predictive equations to provide same muscular activation and same perceived exertion nominal loads during the two exercises. Advantage of Leg Press The ongoing Squats Vs Leg Press battle often make people overlook the overall benefits of both the exercises. The leg press here is the floor equipment, which I consider more effective than the upright leg press, though the upright version has its virtues. First aim was describing Smith machine squat and leg press exercise as nominal load, knee extensors activity, and rating of perceived exertion. Leg Press vs Squats: What’s the Best Lower-Body Move for You? During the hack squat exercise, for example the angle of your hip joint is ~100°, the 45° leg press facilitates an angle of ~85° and on the seated leg press the angle is only ~50°.

Anyone think kicking a soccer ball is better for leg development than squats? of Physical Therapy, University of North Dakota, Grand Forks, ND Abstract: Purpose. Technically speaking, the overhead squat outperformed the back squat for the anterior trunk muscles, as measured by the EMG activity of the rectus abdominis and the external oblique.
Squats zählen zu den wichtigsten Kraftübungen für Beine und Po. But because there is less range of motion than there is with the squat, the quads work harder with this exercise. So what this actually means, is that it indicates the exercises that will, indiscriminately, cause the largest activation of that muscle. Most EMG studies are shit in terms of measuring the best exercise for bodybuilding purposes. Suffice to say, leg presses, leg extensions, and smith machine squats, did not beat out barbell squat and lunge variations in quad activity (although they were all pretty similar). Use The Leg Press If… You need assistance work. The leg press also works the quads, hamstrings and glutes. Second aim was developing predictive equations to provide same muscular activation and same perceived exertion nominal loads during the two exercises. To do that, vastus lateralis and vastus medialis activation, as their summed surface …

The analysis method used was electromyographic (EMG) activity. First aim was describing Smith machine squat and leg press exercise as nominal load, knee extensors activity, and rating of perceived exertion. While this does not lead to an 1:1 reduction in EMG activity, the latter is in fact, -16% and -22,5% smaller for the 85° and 50° hip joint angles on the respective exercises.
Hell, kicking a soccer ball at full strength would most likely register a lot higher on a surface EMG than a 1RM squat. Biomechanics research on the knee has demonstrated that during the squat and leg press, the tibia slides backward. Advantage of Leg Press The best two out of the three are the leg press and barbell squat – though there are hardcore hack machine users who swear that the hack machine is the best. Bigger Bodyparts. Before I conducted my EMG studies, I too, would've sworn that the leg press activated more quad than the squat, at least for taller guys like me (I'm 6'4"). 2000

Q: Is there any significant difference between the squat and leg press with respect to the muscles involved?Can I get by with doing one or the other, or do I need to perform both?

5

One thing to also keep in mind is that when it comes to hamstrings, Romanian deadlifts really are king in terms of EMG activation (as shown here). For several years the fight over which exercise is better for legs has been doing the rounds and unfortunately none of them has managed to found a clear winner. But the leg press is definitely his army general, not afraid to wage war on your quads when the time is needed. And the fact that it’s a unilateral exercise helps balance out asymmetries that would likely develop from using only bilateral exercises like squats and leg press. Though leg presses and squats work the same muscle groups, they do so from slightly different angles and with greater emphasis on one group or the other. As a general phenomenon, both squats and leg presses can never be interchangeable or even remotely equal to each other as they both have their share of pros and cons when it comes to exercising and body building. The best two out of the three are the leg press and barbell squat – though there are hardcore hack machine users who swear that the hack machine is the best.