Bottom line – Nutrisystem VS South Beach Diet, which is the winner? South Beach Diet: Nutrisystem: Food: Low-carb, higher protein and higher fat diet that starts out with a very restrictive two-week opening phase that is then liberalized a bit after 14 days. Concluding Thoughts – Nutrisystem vs the South Beach Diet. Both … They were more likely to slide back into eating calorie-laden diet and gain more weight than with Nutrisystem. South Beach Diet vs Nutrisystem – Pricing. We thought that both Nutrisystem and South Beach Diet offers attractive and effective options for losing weight. Overall, most users have found it hard to stick to a low carb diet after completing the south beach diet plans. If you sign up for the South Beach Diet delivery program, you can choose from 3 different schemes: The Silver Plan (from $7.97/day): … South Beach Diet vs. Nutrisystem - Ultimate Comparison for 2020 South Beach Diet The South Beach Diet is a renowned, healthy and effective meal delivery service based on scientific principles … South Beach Diet. South Beach Diet: Nutrisystem: Food: Low-carb, higher protein and higher fat diet that starts out with a very restrictive two-week opening phase that is then liberalized a bit after 14 days.